How to Make the Ultimate Christmas Ice Cream Sandwich (Featuring Mother’s® Holiday Reindeer Cookies + Blue Bell® Christmas Cookies Ice Cream)
If you’re searching for a festive, fun, and unbelievably delicious holiday dessert, look no further than this Christmas ice cream sandwich made with Mother’s® Holiday Reindeer Cookies and Blue Bell® Christmas Cookies Ice Cream. It’s the perfect no-bake treat that blends crunchy, colorful holiday cookies with creamy, festive ice cream—ideal for parties, family nights, or a sweet moment of holiday indulgence.
In this blog, you’ll learn exactly how to make these cheerful Christmas ice cream sandwiches, get pro tips for assembling them perfectly, and discover creative variations to keep the holiday magic going.
Zero baking required
Kid-friendly + party-friendly
Festive flavors and colors
Perfect blend of crunch and creaminess
This treat is the perfect way to elevate holiday flavors using nostalgic favorites like Mother’s iconic seasonal cookies and Blue Bell’s creamy Christmas Cookies ice cream.
Ingredients
1 bag of Mother’s® Holiday Reindeer Cookies
1 carton of Blue Bell® Christmas Cookies Ice Cream
(A festive blend of sugar cookie, snickerdoodle, and seasonal icing flavors)Optional: holiday sprinkles, crushed candy canes, mini chocolate chips
Equipment
A small spoon or cookie scoop
Parchment paper
Freezer-safe tray
How to Make Christmas Ice Cream Sandwiches
Place parchment paper over the freezer safe tray
Lay one layer of Reindeer Cookies on the bottom of the tray
Using a cookie scoop, scoop a generous portion of Blue Bell Christmas Cookies Ice Cream onto the first layer of cookies, smoothing out the top.
Now, add any sprinkles, candy canes or chocolate chips you want for the center of your sandwich.
Add additional layer of icecream on top of that, then the second layer of cookies on top, making a perfect holiday sandwich.
Now Freeze to Set - Best to freeze overnight.
Grab the parchment paper and pull out of the freezer safe tray, cut with a knife, if you run the knife under warm water it will be easier to cut.
Tips for the Best Christmas Ice Cream Sandwiches
Soften the ice cream slightly (5–8 minutes on the counter) so it spreads easily.
Store extras in airtight containers for up to a week.
For a softer bite, remove sandwiches from the freezer 5 minutes before serving.
Perfect for Holiday Parties & Christmas Movie Nights
These Christmas ice cream sandwiches check all the boxes: festive, nostalgic, easy, and crowd-pleasing. Whether you're hosting a Christmas Eve gathering, planning a holiday dessert table, or just craving something sweet during a cozy movie night, this recipe is guaranteed to be a hit.
Making a Christmas ice cream sandwich using Mother’s Holiday Reindeer Cookies and Blue Bell Christmas Cookies Ice Cream is one of the easiest ways to create a magical holiday treat that everyone will love. Give it a try this season—you may just find your new favorite December dessert tradition.